Sundays at Tiffany’s

Audiobook Review

Who: James Patterson

Why: After A Thousand Splendid Suns, I wanted something light, and I certainly got that with this book. I’d never read anything by Patterson, but I’d heard good things from sources I respect, so I checked out the audiobook from the library. Actually, I requested it and forgot I’d ordered it until it arrived about three weeks later. Big waiting list for this one.

Thoughts: Patterson’s detective series must be way better, because this was not exactly compelling listening. Perhaps much of the fault lies with the reader. Her voice was downright caustic at times, epecially when she was doing the part of glamorous-but-aloof-mother Vivian. Every character is a stereotype, from the ambitious-but-evil-hunk boyfriend to hunk BFs equally superficial agents. And of course Michael, the imaginary friend, is one-dimensional, since he lives in some other dimension and shit.

Yes, I had problems with character development, or lack thereof, and with unresolved plot issues.

Warning: Spoilers ahead – scroll down to the next section if you plan to read this book:

Jane is sick and surely she’s about to die, but no – it’s her mother who checks out. The reader is left to wonder WTF was wrong with Jane there at the end and how she recovered so suddenly and made it to the hospital – just in time, of course.

And her mother’s deathbed confession of why she withheld her affection all of Jane’s life truly strains credibility. Vivian is never developed at all, yet at the end, we’re supposed to believe that all along, she was a warm, loving mother, capable of expressing (more like gushing) love without reservation?  Not to mention that she’s had a stroke, yet she’s completely coherent and able to articulate these feelings for the first time, only a few hours later?

In one scene, Vivian pops in unexpectedly and gives Jane a cryptic warning that heart disease runs in their family – Vivian’s mother died of heart problems when she was in her late 30s, I think she tells Jane. What was that all about? I suppose it was to fool the reader into believing that Jane has heart problems, since Vivian is about 60 at this point.

Then there’s the imaginary friend, another hunk of course. Readers get their first clue that Michael is transforming into a human when he cuts himself shaving. He has no idea who he is or where he came from, and we never find out, either. He has plenty of other 1-D friends, though, who materialize in the hospital waiting room long enough to meet and approve of Jane, before they disappear again.

puzzled-readerRequest for Patterson fans:

Tell me what I’m missing, please. I read that:

“In 2007, one of every fifteen hardcover novels sold was a James Patterson title– totaling an estimated 16 million books sold last year in North America alone. According to Forbes magazine, Patterson earned $50 million from June 2007 to June 2008, placing him second on the list of best paid authors in the world. In total, Patterson’s books have sold an estimated 150 million copies worldwide. He has won awards including the Edgar, the BCA Mystery Guild’s Thriller of the Year, and the International Thriller of the Year award. James Patterson was called “the man who can’t miss” in Time magazine. He is the first author to have #1 new titles simultaneously on The New York Times adult and children’s bestsellers lists, and to have two books on NovelTracker’s top-ten list at the same time. He holds the New York Times bestsellers list record with 39 New York Times bestselling titles overall.”

Wow! One of every 15 books? Is this true? Tell me something good about his other books, besides that they make big bucks – which I greatly respect, btw.



Filed under audiobooks

2 responses to “Sundays at Tiffany’s

  1. jamqueenann

    I have read almost all of James Patterson’s books. This was one of my least favorite. I like the womens murder club series & the Alex Cross books. Also liked Suzanne’s Diary for Nicholas. I like them because the chapters are short & move along quickly & there’s usually a twist at the end you don’t expect.

  2. allthingsarial

    Ann, I checked out some reviews on B&N’s site. Many loyal Patterson readers agreed with you, and a couple of people mentioned Jane’s unresolved illness. I also learned that the co-author for this book usually writes children’s fiction – which explains a great deal!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s